26 Egypt scientific. And who shall say that our Nile dams and land banks and agricultural experts are of greater value than their palaces and mosques and artistic traditions ? Our cotton has brought foreign trade to Egypt, but it is their culture that has brought the tourist traffic. Yet there is no doubt but that they cost the native Egyptian far more than we did. They took in taxation practically the whole produce of the soil beyond the barest livelihood of the fellaheen. Their tolls on the transit trade, equivalent to the original cost of the goods, prevented any competi- tion with the sea route round the Cape. Their struggle with the Turks for the right to exploit Egypt caused perpetual disturbance, while their acceptance of Islam cut the country off from participation in European progress. It looked at one time as though this Mameluke system of white slave rule over Asiatic and African races might win the world for the Eastern Islamic State, much as our system of commercial colonisation has subsequently won it for European industrial civilisation. At the time of their overthrow by the Turks a Mameluke fleet was dis- puting the future Empire of India with the Portuguese, and late in the eighteenth century the Mamelukes under Ali looked like becoming the successors of the Turks in the Ottoman Empire. But thereafter their day was over. The war-slave was succeeded by the wage-slave in the empire of the world, and India was ruled by the Griffin, not the Grouz ; moreover, the military art of the Mamelukes became antiquated. Their armies were still made up of feudal contingents, commanded by a chief, and composed of lesser beys or barons, of Mamelukes or men-at-arms, and of swarms of foot soldiers and fol- lowers. Their military art was that of the Crusades, and their arms were copied or even captured from* those of