to the overwhelming as opposed to the un general assembly. but palestine is a bid for full membership. in that case, the rise income, the nation of israel, is on the gaza for the us as it will veto the motion again at the security council for different codes, the resolution make. this is inside story, the

hello and welcome to the program and the bulk of the international community has debated palestinian statehood for decades. full membership of the united nations would effectively recognize that sweeping support of the general assembly is the 1st step for the final seal of approval. come to some of the un security council. last month, the united states have vetoed a resolution table by algeria and says it will do so we can. so count the maureen, weights of world opinion reflect to the un general assembly pressure of the us to reconsider. what difference could the backing of a $143.00 nations make to palestine? no men, but special observer status will explore these and other issues. so i guess in a moment profess the support bi, catch. a lopez taught in condemnation of israel's neuron. garza has led to protest like these from santa, in the human to jordan's capital. i'm a on the rallies in solidarity with palestinians at 1st to cools. and

us universities have spread around the world. and at the united nations, the general assembly voted over willingly to grant new rights and privileges to palestine. it's also calling on the security council to reconsider palestine sped to become a full union member. we want peace, we want freedom, and yes vote is a vote for the palestinian existence. it is not against any state. israel says the move is absurd, especially after her mazda is attack on october, the 7th. while using a prop, the is really impasse that are said, the resolution disregards un statutes. you are reading the your in charts or with your own hands. yes, yes. that's what you're doing. writing,

do you on charter? a shame on you. the un vote may be widely symbolic, but it comes as country such as spain, ireland, and other evil members plan to formally recognize the state of palestine on may 20 . first. the international community overwhelmingly overwhelmingly saying that i want that long term resolution to the conflict and that, that involves 2 states. despite new rights and privileges. palestine remains a non member observer, say that the un without the right to vote. and the us has made is clear, it will use that to feed all power to blog post in, in membership and statehood until the important issues are resolved with israel capielo pacific. again, how do 0 for insights story the

quite well that spring, and i guess now from a room where joined by jeffrey sachs, he's a full, i'm a special advisor to the you and 60 general now the director of the center for sustainable development at columbia university and romano and stuff about go see is the general secretary of the posting and national initiative and in london is you'll see macro back and associate fellow at the middle east and north africa program. i the you tasting time. chatham house of, i will welcome to will see if you're welcome to a inside story. you'll see, i wonder if i can start with you if you could help us set the scene. because until now, palestine has only held the status of an observer at the un. what does the pulsing, the overwhelming pulsing office say? your resolution? what does that mean in terms of the rights and privileges of forwarded to palestine? now in science a product doesn't change too much because it's the secure with the concept of that site. so there's a notion will actually be through a recognition as

a states. but i think symbolically it is a very important, it is important step forward in the reach of molding. hundreds and salty states actually very clearly declared that in going to see probably starting to recognize as, as, as, as a state. and at the same time, it's known to everyone that the only country that blocks a ballistic and states would from being good information in the back of the nice is the united states. what of the united states is moving slowly in different direction when it comes to its relation? so we're still active states, i think moving towards sets and probably a in the, if this is the direction we might see the united states also to one point to another, hopefully soon phone. and what's the general assembly just said yesterday in the vehicle like splitting and states. geoffrey following on from that amongst some of the rights and privileges now forwarded. the palestinians has the right to be seated among member states,

alphabetically. an ability also to submit proposals that amendments directly without having to do it through another country. as you will see says, so these are, these seem to be a slight move forward when it comes to what the posting of states is really looking forward to is this largely symbolic that as well. it's important, it's more than symbolic. it demonstrates were world opinion is overwhelmingly, and it is correct. the united states is the sole obstacle actually not only to palestine membership in the united nations as the 194th member. but actually, united states has the sole ops to go on my view to peace in the region. because with the membership with sovereignty, with the implementation, now they globally recognize state on the 1967 borders with capital and east jerusalem and control over these land mccauley. sites there would also be the

ability to have peace with the countries of the region as in the air, a peace initiative, and then the era but and as like a leadership statement and who re odd last november. so the united states has found a way blocking a palestinian state. it's blocking piece, it's blocking piece on behalf of a radical extremist, a violent is re government, which is committing a massive war crimes. so, and quite likely the i, c, j will rule a genocide. this is what the united states is enabling right now. it's absolutely distressing for me as an american to see this young people, people on my campus were a guest at what the disadvantage gratian is doing. i said, certainly, all of this conversation at ega, this, by the 2 of you have spoken so far, to focus on the obstacles that are clearly in the way when it comes to publish

times full membership. well, before we go into the obstacles, i must offer turning to you if this decision for the un means anything is where you are, your reaction to what played out to the you and as well. it means a lot the besides the symbolic aspect of it, it sends a message, a very powerful political message. the world is full, right? that ice was published in used to be free for a more cubic stream from the system of apartheid from this started. but the general side that is happening on the line we are talking by the way that isn't it is committing kind of a domestic us at this very moment. and that's fine. and inside does the city and as a, to a neighborhood. and in japan, you trying to, if they click lens one more time japan your area. so of course, the whole world just sending a very powerful message to us that they don't accept what's happening to better students. but more than that, i think this a lot that took place expose how i used to lead to the united states on visitor.

and uh, you'll have to remember that the united states of america, this you as bio and is a good not to mobilize more than 3. come to this to work with them on sending the others are hello mike going easy are much rely on is it is and united states itself . i mean with all due respect, these little islands, don't really miami. i mean, we all know that they, they, they, what, according to what the american students saw up in the attitude, this is huge eyes relation of, of the american post. right? one moment please. and also it shows how i related the fact that the united states have stuck to the membership in there. and i did mention security council, it is totally unacceptable. i'm the saying that right? absolutely. we will delve no doubt into us obstruction as you say. i want to the

practically speaking with stuff uh, given what is played out of the you and whether practically this makes any difference to the suffering of palestinians in gaza on palestinians and the occupied westbank a not a lot of the not enough sort of fluid. it's very little if you compare it to what needs to be done, nothing else behavior in uh on data mining. what was it possible that good event sort of cease fire when harm us accepted what was proposed to them by the united states, egypt and after they were told that is an acceptance and once from us accepted. this is the mind. it's a, i'm nothing you know initiated is enough, i hope, but ition which was not to be limited to the eastern side, but not the thought of the or the expand to defend to other areas. and i'm sure he will not stop him. he finishes the destruction of which means this direction for those guys a strip. the only thing that would stop nothing you know,

is sanctions. immediately there has to be a military sanctions that it has to be kind of exceptions that it has to be the options by all these governments that kept telling us for the last 2 months, the data against the investor and doing nothing. when he is going to think this step in muster could, i'm talking about you to be honest, i'm talking about and i just states of america i'm talking about even though out of countries, this has to be stopped and it can be sold all of the with the immediate functions don't, right, right. let me bring it in there and you'll see because said katie, as we've heard that from the stuff up practically on it, so this and han stage of the un this and han status for palestine of the un. what on his own make much of a difference, a tool without a multi pronged approach sanctions is something of course the stuff or reiterate to that. but does this, does this though at least paved the way for full membership?

sometime in the not too distant future, you'll see. i think it fits the foot here. when i say symbolic symbolism in diplomacy is important. and i think it sends a clear message. what there was things, i think again we have edging closer to recognition for what we mean, some practices that by the student and state existing 11 shape or form. it's about the recognition. so it says that there is leadership only know we know the territorial 4th is a future, a listing and state. so this, this is the, it's about how he personalized and how he changes the relationship between and at home, the negotiation type. and when he eventually comes between days and, and palestinians know, but at the same time, the most important thing try now is to stop the war. because this is not going to change or the period of 5 find the paper of the guys and doing cuz i know this is the, this doesn't stop set to the finance,

this is doesn't bring us much closer into ending this conflict best. so the concentration should be so difficult condition by the starting offer state is important as file to fit much big move to fall to the peace process. and the police do i know by listening to your very, very key to talk about the obstacles in the way of palestine becoming a full member of the un turning to you jeffrey, the main stumbling bulk. as we've said, remains that the un security council, where just remind all view is at least 9 affirmative votes and no veto from any of the 5 permanent members is required. the problem is we've all said, hey, so the moment a key member of the united states repeatedly vote against recognizing the palestinians as a independent state, claiming it would be, quote, home full for peace jeffrey. can you explain what they mean by harmful piece? the rationale behind this, the us,

the politics is dominated by the israel lobby. it's very simple. the washington political class has cited with israel, no matter what israel has done up to and including genocide. it's not complicated, but the american public is against is the young people are shocked, dismayed and out on the campuses across the country. and then the congress and the administrators of these universities bring into place to bash their heads and to call and the place. so this is extremely unpopular in the united states, but this is a political class that is, i really guy led by the israel lobby. i think what is important is the whole more i make clear to the united states. you alone are blocking piece. now this is a, what do i,

the palestinian ambassador said yesterday at the u. n. and a very powerful speech and bassett, or re a bunch or in a very eloquent and powerful speech. these railey ambassador guy, i, earhart, gave the single worst and most disgraceful speech that i recall and listening to hundreds of speeches in the un general assembly. during the past 25 years of my work with the un. absolutely, a speech of hate and a speech of war. uh and uh, but he was counting on uh, a political class in washington that it will stand by israel. it won't stand by israel right long under this because the american public opinion is absolutely against this. and for absolutely good reason, let's turn to the software again because the us has also claimed that the recognition of palestinian statehood would, quote,

undermine efforts to resume negotiations between its railways. palestinians essentially rewarding the palestinians for whipping up international pressure on israel and effectively rewarding the armed, waiting or from us as a lot of jihad and other groups for carrying out violence. what you make of this argument by the united states and stuff are the for the hypocrites, is it so such an amount of a focus you one day nighted states and some european countries keep talking about the 2 state solution and advocate for the 2 state solution and at the same time doesn't do not even nice bye bye. and not only that, they do not say that is a must and this will q based on those by the senior. this is land does not input. so commission, how can we have a states, where do we have it in the dashboard or i'm to the, i'm not saying that is it

a must dismantle all the systems that exist now in the west bank without angels. and without that, we will not have a listing and state. so what you see here is a huge amount of boxes see by these countries. that's all they do by talking about posted solutions. all they mean is to give it a more time to continue the process of set them into building. and so i'm an extension of the west bank. i'm kidding. so there's any possibility of about a city and state. look at what's happening there, is that our thoughts? there is this, it is a lucian in the nations, which is this paper. but in the end, if you, on the ground what there's nothing you all doing. he's gloss, think off the story, and i need to find the context between i mean, the scene and, and any other country by taking over the phone and the sync with egypt. this is one of the destructive acts that is aiming, appealing to the possibility of a 2 state solution. so this american position and finally on open positions of

nothing but the hypocrisy, they are hypocritical and to speak only about 2 states without tickles. and i think that the thing is deep and one more thing. i think when the whole and what sol, how the isn't a lead delegates. eh, i don't country, should i have the chart of thought of the united nations in front of everybody over the simply, what does that mean to send the message that there's the bottom below, above, international and punitive to international law. and that could not try to happen to accept it without the american phone and so forth. to is there, you'll say tony too much stuff. uh, it's very, very adamant tennessee. you'll see a most of it is very, very adamant that there's a huge amount of hypocrisy. there's absolutely no incentive, whatsoever for israel to ever recognize a palestinian state while it goes about accelerating its settlement building. and they don't divide west by end of cost. both jeffrey and the staff are,

i refer to that send me the article moment after you adding which of the deal out of the the is already on buses for you and shredded the you and charles a accusing the u. n. of appeasing, circle, terrace, laden, polished, and unit. uh, politicians will be a party who wants to kill or is re lease and use. it's the policy you'll see is the policy. well, this resolution it any way a violation of the un charter as is right allowed to use of is not in there. unfortunately, i'm bus of the needs building more when these is inc, until the nation multiple the see at the. busy the you and instead of substance a piece actually double for, for the united mission to decide to about recognition of, of, of the states of node and all this kind of feel of should i bring the child to. i

don't think he covers in says favorite globally and not the country either present . this is highly regressive or right. i also don't take dog. they'll simply stick a view that if the only change days or the government's really more for or the officer consult these the other elements out. so these, that the officer consult based but it needs a change of government. it needs a change of direction and we felt a yes, i agree that is also in the united states and the mean time that was offered boca safe if the united states believes in a 2 state solution. let's move. busy to the full recognition of the state to it is a conviction part of the negotiation. but for this face and then for the boss isn't in palestine on a quarter for thing that they can negotiate to be fun each other refunded not the states. and then we follow the other outstanding issues from joe is the name is the capital of both the refugees and both is and then settlements and the rest as to

state the building with each other we've, we've, we've 1st sponsibility and, and re for the, for spect and best we haven't seen, and that's what's my life change. so if they all are going to be future negotiations, they must be on a level playing field with respect and responsibility on both sides of the equation . just returning to you again because i also want to look at one of the all the apparent obstacles for palestine being a full member of the you and it comes some concerns about setting a precedent for all the observed countries that always sparring to full membership or the you and i'm thinking of cost of, of and it's tensions which sub yes tie. one is the tensions with china. well, offering full membership to palestine complicates similar power level situations elsewhere in the world. cost of all taiwan know this has been the will of the

international community and core to international law for at least 57 years since the 1967 war. the notion that there need to be 2 states, of course, goes back a even 2 decades before that a, this is a long and specific history. there needs to be a political self determination for palestine and the state of palestine is un member state i. this is not in any way a dangerous precedent. this is quite the contrary. this is a protection of basic political rights that have been recognized for decades. why the us position is, is not only deep, fully hypocritical. it's profoundly cynical because what it says is, well, let the parties decide that knowing that israel says no. so it has given a veto to the state of having a state of palestine to israel,

to the occupier. this is an absurdity of, but this is the us position. we don't want to decide on the state of palestine because israel needs to negotiate that. are you kidding? the occupying power? the government that says greater is real. we control everything. that's the one that has the veto, overt palestinian self determination. that's the actual us position. i don't know how much is cynical, how much is bought off and how much they're fools. but they have been blocking piece for decades, steps to us. i did all 3 of us being very vehement and i'm picking unraveling the obstacles in the way when it comes to post on the full membership of the you. and i wonder if we can look ahead to what full membership would mean if and when it happens. most stuff, or israel was granted full membership of view and 75 years ago. today,

paula stein is still, as we all know, very much waiting. what would it mean to be negotiating with israel, as we've mentioned before, on this level, playing field state to state. well, uh, let me remind you that when is it and was it a good night to bite you on? uh, did we have 2 conditions that desire and have to fulfill the events on sentence, which is the fact that the one in one design use and said that it wouldn't be able to see me and states. yeah, is definitely about happens answer kind of that is read with implement the 194 is addition, which would allow us to obviously use that with displaced by is are in to come back home. also they did not implement that. so practically, the, it isn't on the mind. it's membership by not. so i'm sending these conditions. that's one second. yes, there is a fabulous conclusion of palestine on the next step. think it does that for them. but because that would mean that every major is at least half a month,

and they're very much of an exception. it has no political and economic value. i mean, that would mean this is a state level to be sure that would be absolute sales. but i have to say that even when the palestinians on some other countries as opposed to the united states of plans for the city is a fast associates to negotiations with is relative to the united states. that if you start to plan the link and this has to say, accepted on, so you have to negotiate the think with is it a n y, right? right. took a this is a use in, in the, in the bottom with 99 members out of 100 time jewish ma'am. but less than the stuff i'm using. the other thing in the 2nd team, the whether we're approaching the end of the program and i want to focus now. busy what a palestinian state would like. so was a follow up to you, my staff. and of course what it would look like maybe into an entirely separate show but them. but given a huge disillusionment with the status quote of that particularly. and they all get

part of westbank, the failure to hold elections and you know, in close to almost 2 decades now. how ready, how ready is progress time to state that the sign has to be completed for a long time? look, we've been me states and they've got we've been to many states and other countries . we are so equipped academically where we have to look. this is typically with resources with people who are so capable. it's adult q patient that is preventing us more than that is it? and is that on forming intellect? flesh structure. this government is fascist, by all means. and that's the obstacle. it's not the lack of what it is on the sides of the palestinians or the need for the form of the claim. the problem is the patient, the system of type, the fascism that is going on, that will not to be sold without sanctions, without boy,

without effect of policy. that says to, is it and, and must, is enough. and for the single furnace demands. and is there any, is b, 's has to come and they cannot come without the freedom of the understanding and people, or as you say, peace cannot come without the freedom of the policy and people, it has been a, a fascinating discussion, a very, very interesting journey with all 3 of you, jeffrey sachs, some stuff about gucci, you'll see macro back. thank you very much for joining us on inside story. i'd like you to for watching and you can see the program again, any time by visiting our website, how to 0, a dot com for further discussion. go to our facebook page. as facebook dot com forward slash a inside story. you can also join the conversation on x i'll handle is at a inside story for me to talk with the whole team here. bye. for now, the

al jazeera brings you in depth analysis for the so comply take. now what has been exposed, many of those companies that failed so miserably on that day, they said 75, selling and testing with any same jobs as we speak, these really speak every one's. no, we're giving each tone finishing the fact that each ease at the international court of justice shows how much deeper than nothing you on the east coast, nothing yahoo success and maybe better, maybe one of us. but it's the one that has to address that systemic problem. stay with us for the latest developments on out jesse era after a controversial presidential campaign. and the contested victory proposed to be unto is said to lead indonesia, southeast asia is the largest economy that drive us nation with more than $1300.00 ethnic groups. political power comes through the people. we're not going to be determined by for in none of this,

the presidents alexis, indonesia, proposed to be unto talks to l, just 0. the canyon government has ordered thousands of people across the country to move away from wetlands that have flooded many areas. torrential rains in the region have been made was by the el nino where the phenomenon. this is how close the houses are from the narrow that down. it doesn't look like margins covered by what the highest says when it will bus knows the what comes to that, how is this? the problem in that ruby has been watson by pull drainage and he's taken the bill. settlement people's beeping in near the narrow be down say they know they're not supposed to be there, but it's the only place they can afford. in depth analysis of the days headlines, if that was a rough or offensive, where would the people go? people have no place to go. each one of 1000 people has to be displaced at least 2

times frank assessments. this is a max and blow to free speech and freedom of the press informed opinions you can be somebody. this is on one of the hostages. october, 7th, and return. and i want the chilly to stop inside story on al jazeera. the hello, i'm about this and, and this is the news on life from doha. coming up in the next 16 minutes targeting palestinians already displaced. is there any error strikes from vol, jamalia, and northern guns unlawful. i'm catastrophic. the from james is really evacuation orders in eastern rafa. hundreds of files and so one second.